Between Silicon and Soul
    Sign InJoin the Conversation
    Trend · Commerce
    Watch Now

    The Aggregation of Commerce

    When the Channel Owns the Customer

    A handful of aggregators — Amazon, Walmart, TikTok Shop, Instacart, and a thin tail behind them — now mediate the majority of product discovery in the United States. They have captured the demand signal, the retail-media margin, and increasingly the customer relationship itself.
    ~40%
    Share of U.S. e-commerce that flows through Amazon's marketplace and ad network.
    Source · eMarketer, 2024
    63%
    Of all U.S. product searches now begin on Amazon, not Google.
    Source · Jungle Scout / Statista
    $50B+
    Annual Amazon advertising revenue — now the third-largest digital ad business in the world.
    Source · Amazon 10-K, 2023
    1.3×
    Premium aggregator-stocked SKUs command in shelf visibility versus organic listings.
    Source · Marketplace Pulse / Profitero
    Composite Portrait

    A product's path through the aggregator.

    The transaction below takes ninety seconds. Every step of it is owned, measured, and monetized by the channel. The brand's role has been reduced to fulfillment and a star rating.

    Search
    Customer types 'wireless headphones under $80' into Amazon.
    Sponsored slot 1 has paid $1.40+ per click for the placement.
    Discovery
    Top six results are sponsored or Amazon Basics.
    Organic rank 1 receives roughly a quarter of the click share it would have in 2018.
    Decision
    Customer reads 4.3-star reviews, ignores the seller name.
    Brand identity has collapsed into a star rating and a thumbnail.
    Conversion
    One-click checkout, Prime delivery, no friction.
    Brand-direct site loses the transaction without ever being considered.
    Re-purchase
    Reorders from order history. Brand is now interchangeable.
    The relationship is between the customer and Amazon, not the brand.
    Data
    Amazon retains every signal. The brand sees almost none of it.
    First-party data — the asset every CMO claims to want — is owned by the channel.

    The brand pays for the click, pays a marketplace fee on the sale, and receives no usable customer signal in return. The aggregator monetizes the same transaction three times.

    “The internet's natural shape is aggregation. The brand's natural shape is differentiation. The two are now in open conflict, and the brand is losing on every battlefield it accepted.”
    — Ben Thompson, Stratechery
    The Terrain

    Five forces inside the aggregator economy.

    Discovery Has Been Captured

    Amazon, TikTok Shop, Instagram, and a handful of marketplace players now mediate the majority of product discovery. Brand-direct discovery — type the URL into a browser — has shrunk to a niche behavior.

    Retail Media is the New Margin Pool

    Amazon Ads, Walmart Connect, Instacart Ads, and TikTok's commerce stack now extract the brand margin that used to sit between manufacturer and shelf. The aggregators monetize attention twice — once on impression, once on conversion.

    Private Label is the Quiet Threat

    Once an aggregator has the demand data, the supply chain, and the shelf, it builds the product itself. Amazon Basics, Walmart's brands, and the platform-native labels are growing faster than the categories they live in.

    Brand Has Been Reduced to a Star Rating

    Within an aggregator, brand equity collapses into reviews, badges, and price. Decades of brand investment can be displaced by a competitor with a better thumbnail and a cheaper shipping promise.

    DTC is No Longer a Standalone Strategy

    The DTC bet — own the customer, own the data, own the margin — has hit the wall of customer-acquisition cost. Most digitally native brands now route the majority of revenue through aggregators and use DTC for storytelling, not scale.

    The Pattern

    What the evidence keeps showing.

    The aggregators are the new shelf — and they own it.

    Shelf placement used to be a category-management negotiation between buyer and brand. Now it is an algorithmic auction owned by the channel, run on the channel's data, and re-run every minute.

    First-party data is the asset most brands have already lost.

    Even brands that 'own' a CRM rarely own the discovery signal. The aggregator sees what the customer browsed, considered, and abandoned. The brand sees only the eventual transaction.

    Concentration risk is now strategic risk.

    When a single channel drives 40–70% of category sales, a fee change, an algorithm tweak, or a private-label launch is an existential event for the brands inside it.

    The escape routes are narrow but real.

    Brands that maintain a coherent identity off-channel — community, content, retail experience, or genuine product superiority — retain pricing power inside the channel. Pure marketplace plays do not.

    Share Your Voice

    Join the conversation to share your thoughts and help others understand this topic better.

    Join the Conversation

    Community Feedback

    No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!